In a tape released two days after the eighth anniversary of the September 11th attacks, Al-Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden reasserted his threat to the United States, calling President Barack Obama "powerless" to stop the war in Afghanistan, reports The Associated Press.
According to Fox News, jihadist forums experienced technical problems on the eve of September 11th. Bin Laden's audiotape finally disseminated throughout the internet via As-Sahab Media on September 13th, 2009.
Foreign Policy's Marc Lynch comments on his frustration with locating the tape on the internet, saying that he experienced difficulties downloading the video once he finally located it on a jihadist forum. He remarks that Al-Qaeda "really does have problems with its distribution mechanisms."
While Fox News states that Al-Qaeda’s videos have grown in technical sophistication, this latest recording does not enjoy high production values. The video, which simply consists of a recorded voice attributed to Osama Bin Laden and a still image of Al-Qaeda's leader, is approximately 11 minutes long.
In addition to his commentary on President Obama's administration and the war in Afghanistan, bin Laden identified America's support of Israel as the root of the conflict. He asked Americans to reconsider their priorities. According to the SITE Intelligence Group's translation of the Al-Qaeda leader's speech, bin Laden said, "Ask yourselves to determine your position: Is your security, your blood...and your reputation dearer to you than the security of the Israelis, their children, and their economy?"
Bin Laden also recommended a couple of texts in his speech, mentioning American authors John Mearsheimer and Steve Walt and their book The Israel Lobby and US Foreign Policy. In his blog at Foreign Policy, Walt wryly responds to bin Laden's book recommendation.
He says that bin Laden's comments about the pro-Israel lobby are "not exactly a news flash" and adds that bin Laden must have missed the part of the Mearsheimer and Walt book which maintains that the United States should still defend the existence of Israel.
How relevant and significant are the contents of Osama bin Laden's speech, eight years after the tragic events of September 11th?
At Foreign Policy, Stephen Walt claims that if the United States pursued a smarter policy in the Middle East, "Bin Laden's call to arms would fall on deaf ears and he'd become even more irrelevant than he is today."
Others take a more cautious approach in analyzing the latest speech and commenting on the last eight years. Lynch views bin Laden's new approach, which downplays extremist "salafi" themes, as an indication that the radical group may have learned from its past mistakes. He says that bin Laden's latest speech may better appeal to the mainstream Muslim world, as it focuses on political conflicts rather than polarizing ideological issues.
Peter Henne at The Huffington Post remains wary of dismissing Al-Qaeda and Osama bin Laden as an insignificant threat. He states that even eight years later, the imminence has faded but the uncertainty remains. Henne says, "Confusing this uncertainty with an actual decline in Al-Qaeda's significance, however, is misguided."
He notes that Al-Qaeda still has a presence in countries such as Algeria and Yemen. Henne states that Al-Qaeda’s greatest weapon is its voice and the threat it will hijack discourse in the Muslim world. He applauds American President Barack Obama for his public diplomacy campaign, which may create a positive image of the United States within Muslim societies.
Across the Atlantic, The Telegraph also views the current state of bin Laden, Al-Qaeda, and the Taliban in a pessimistic light. The UK-based newspaper’s website reminds readers that 67 British citizens were killed in the World Trade Center attacks of September 11th.
The article also mentions a recent case in which three British Muslims were convicted for conspiring to destroy transatlantic airliners using liquid-based bombs. Although the threat appears to be less significant today, The Telegraph uses this case as an example to point out that the security threat posed by terrorism still remains throughout the world. The article concludes, "As that tragic day showed, the enemy is both real and deadly."